Ok, so everyone says you should go for the cheeseburgers... and granted, they're great. However, you REALLY want to make sure you save room for the Key Lime Pie. They've been trying to keep the place secret for ages so the locals don't have to wait so long during tourist season, but they recently had the whole place repainted, so I guess they're trying to get some attention these days. The rustic decor is adorned with toilets and bath tubs and they do NOT take credit cards. Great place if you're looking for Florida atmosphere and good food - but it's outside dining on the water, so don't expect white glove service. Oh, and don't feed the birds! :)