Ok, so everyone says you should go for the cheeseburgers... and granted, they're great. However, you REALLY want to make sure you save room for the Key Lime Pie. They've been trying to keep the place secret for ages so the locals don't have to wait so long during tourist season, but they recently had the whole place repainted, so I guess they're trying to get some attention these days. The rustic decor is adorned with toilets and bath tubs and they do NOT take credit cards. Great place if you're looking for Florida atmosphere and good food - but it's outside dining on the water, so don't expect white glove service. Oh, and don't feed the birds! :)
My wife and I decided to do a little staycation for our anniversary last year. I found the Omphoy through Priceline - got a great deal looking for 3+ star hotels in the area. We knew nothing of the hotel when we booked, but can tell you it's now our favorite little getaway. Omphoy is a new boutique hotel right on the beach with a very Euro feel. The staff was incredibly friendly, service was impeccable, and the amenities very nice. They have an Exhale Spa on site, which was absolutely fantastic. We got his and hers massages on short notice and took advantage of the sauna as well. They have a Michy's Restaurant on site as well, which overlooks the ocean. The food was truly unbelievable. The server found out it was our anniversary and had the pastry chef ad Happy Anniversary to our dessert. One word for their Dreamsicle Dessert: Orgasmic! We can't wait to go back!!
They've won Best Pizza in Palm Beach for something like 30 years in a row. In 2009 they were voted Best Restaurant in Palm Beach County - pretty impressive. The food is phenomenal - I've yet to have anything from the menu that I didn't like, but I would particularly recommend the Pizza and anything Fra Diavlo if you like spicy. I like the Eggplant Pizza, though I ask to add Pepperoni just to spice it up. The stuffed mushrooms are divine! Service is always great - small intimate place where you can actually have a conversation over a nice meal. It's also called 'The Art Gallery Restaurant' because of the art collection, which is pretty impressive. Same owners for over 30 years - same manager (Vinny) for almost 2 decades.. obviously, they're doing something right!